|
Preston Manning, Brian Stiller, and John Stackhouse comment on Obama's victory.
By Jim Coggins
 THE AMERICAN election last Tuesday may have constituted a victory for president-elect Barack Obama, the Democratic Party, African-Americans and racial harmony. But it represented "a very difficult choice for conservative Christians," according to one Canadian commentator.
The problem was that there was no candidate that evangelicals could feel totally comfortable with, said John G. Stackhouse, Sangwoo Youtong Chee Professor of Theology and Culture at Regent College in Vancouver. Republican John McCain is not an evangelical, has been divorced and is not as strongly pro-life as many evangelicals would like. The Democrat, Obama, is a "church-going Christian" but is also pro-choice on the abortion question.
"no candidate that evangelicals could feel totally comfortable with"
John G. Stackhouse - Regent College |
As a result, many evangelical leaders "sat on their hands" in this election, said Stackhouse. The appointment of Sarah Palin as the Republican vice-presidential nominee galvanized some evangelicals, but she proved to be "not as bright and pure as some evangelicals had hoped," in addition to coming across as overly ambitious and out of her depth.
White evangelical support was crucial to giving Republican George W. Bush his narrow election victories in 2000 and 2004. But while Bush won 79% of the white evangelical vote in 2004, McCain won only 74% this year. That is not a huge change, but it was significant because white evangelicals represented 23% of voters this year. Moreover, Obama did better among evangelicals in "swing states" -- states where the election was close -- and among young evangelicals, gaining 32% of the votes of white evangelicals aged 18-29.
Obama won only 43% of the vote of weekly churchgoers but 75% of those affiliated with no religion. Obama won 94% of the vote of those who attend black churches and 54% of Roman Catholics -- a figure that includes 47% of white Catholics and 72% of Hispanic Catholics.
 | | Brian Stiller |
Black churches in the US have a "rich political heritage", said Brian Stiller, president of Tyndale University College and Seminary in Toronto. They are sometimes considered to be evangelical because they worship like evangelical and charismatic churches. However, their theological tradition is quite different.
There have been widespread accusations that Obama is not really a Christian because he doesn't espouse evangelical values. However, Obama is being "true to his religious tradition," said Paul Rowe, associate professor in political studies at Trinity Western University in Langley, BC.
Black churches have always had an emphasis on "liberation theology" or the social gospel, the application of the gospel in this world. They have an emphasis on religious experience but do not have a well-developed theology. Black churches have strongly supported the Democratic Party in the past, but not in the overwhelming numbers they did this time.
Roman Catholics represent about the same percentage of the US population as evangelicals, but have not tended to vote as a bloc. Obama's running mate, Joe Biden, is a Roman Catholic, but downplays his religious identity and has been sharply criticized by Roman Catholic Church leaders for policies such as his pro-choice stand.
Changes in evangelicalism
For Republicans to assume that evangelicals would automatically vote for them because of the hot button issues of abortion and homosexuality was a big mistake, said Stiller. There may still be "pockets of single-issue Christians" in the US, but evangelical concerns are generally broader than that. Young evangelicals in both the US and Canada are increasingly interested in issues such as poverty and the environment.
"US evangelicals are also human beings and Americans," said Stackhouse, suggesting that their voting decisions were influenced by issues such the economic crisis, just like other Americans. "Evangelicals don't vote just on religious considerations."
 | | Paul Rowe |
"The issues evangelicals feel are important are diversifying," Rowe said, noting a widespread sense that the Republicans have mismanaged foreign policy and economic policy. "Young evangelical voters are still not pro-abortion but may feel that issue has been settled for now. They want a more progressive foreign policy."
Stiller added: "The Religious Right is highly fragmented over the failure of the Bush administration in many areas, including the lack of progress (to limit) abortion and gay rights."
In the last days of the election campaign, Focus on the Family founder James Dobson released a 'Letter from 2012' which predicted dire consequences from an Obama victory. These consequences included the entrenchment of abortion rights, the legalization of same-sex marriage, the silencing of Christians, the prohibition of gun ownership, nationalized medicine (a medicare system similar to Canada's), military gains by militant Islam and the Soviet Union, and economic disaster in the US.
"The issues evangelicals feel are important are diversifying"
Paul Rowe - TWU |
The letter exemplified Dobson's position as the most prominent remaining leader of the Religious Right, which is now an unorganized movement but is the successor to the Moral Majority organization formed by televangelist Jerry Falwell to elect President Ronald Reagan in 1980. It was this same evangelical bloc that helped elect Republican George W. Bush in 2000 and 2004.
Dobson's letter was severely criticized by some other evangelicals, most notably Jim Wallis, founder of the evangelical social action group Call to Renewal and author of the new book The Great Awakening: Reviving Faith & Politics in a Post-Religious Right America.
The leadership of the US evangelical movement is changing, said Stiller. Falwell and James Kennedy have died, and Pat Robertson is pretty much "a spent force."
 | | John G. Stackhouse |
Stackhouse noted that the "most prominent evangelical spokespeople" in the US -- those with TV shows and big book contracts -- have almost always been on the extreme right wing. It is not clear whether this is because people with other outlooks don't watch religious television or because there is something about the medium of television that "leans toward dramatic, extreme and simple" presentations. He suggested that televangelists have never been representative of the full spectrum of the evangelical movement.
Rowe, Stiller and Stackhouse all suggested that the new face of US evangelicalism may be Rick Warren of Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, California. Warren is pro-life but has also supported ministry to AIDS victims in Africa and other social causes. Warren invited both McCain and Obama to his church to talk about their personal faith and the issues in mid-August. Stiller said Warren is "more reflective of the evangelical community than the Religious Right has ever been."
Impact on issues
Because of the election, "there will be a decline in the significance of religion in terms of public importance," Rowe suggested, and Democrats "will try to pull religion out of public life." However, he added, it would be a mistake to overstate that. "America is a deeply religious country, and nothing has changed about that."
Rowe pointed out that a proposition banning same-sex marriage passed in California, even though the state voted strongly for Obama. Arizona and Florida passed similar propositions. Therefore, the Democratic Party should not think it has "a blank cheque," Rowe warned. "The Democratic Party does not represent the broad scope of Christian or American culture on issues such as abortion." He added that the Democratic Party's move to the left in the 1960s sowed the seeds for the rise of the Religious Right in the 1980s.
On the other hand, "just because you are paranoid doesn't mean they aren't out to get you," Stackhouse quipped. Both Stackhouse and Rowe stated that Dobson's strongest argument was that Obama will have the power to make appointments to the Supreme Court. That could lead to decisions in favour of abortion and same-sex marriage and even to restrictions on the freedom of Christians to talk about those issues. Dobson cited instances from Canada on the latter point.
However, "even well vetted justices don't do what you thought they would do," as has been proven by the conservative justices appointed by Republicans, said Stackhouse. "Judges have a habit of thinking for themselves." As well, there are numerous "checks and balances" in the US system, and "things take a long time."
Stackhouse considered it "very likely" that, if present trends continue, same-sex marriage will be approved in the US and other English-speaking democracies -- because it will be "framed as a matter of individual human rights." However, he added that "history doesn't always move in one direction." In particular, there is an axiom that "hemlines fall with the stock market" -- that is, economic hard times tend to push society in a more conservative direction.
Continue article >>
|
 | | Preston Manning |
Preston Manning, founder of the Reform Party in Canada and now president and CEO of the Manning Centre for Building Democracy, said there is a pendulum in American politics, and in the next election, it could swing back the other way.
While there is "room for concern" about current trends, it would be a mistake to keep fighting the same battles in the same ways, he said. For instance, because of the discovery that DNA contains the entire genetic code of a person, "it is increasingly difficult to maintain that personhood only begins at birth," said Manning. "Science is changing the framework."
Christians are not changing the nature of their concerns but "getting wiser in what political action to take," said Manning. "Christians are called to be as wise as serpents and as gracious as doves -- and more believers are learning what that means."
Application to Canada
What happens in the US usually has some impact in Canada. The Roman Catholic Church has expressed some concern that an "assisted suicide" proposition that passed in Washington state -- and that is similar to a proposition passed in Oregon a few years ago -- may encourage assisted suicide proponents here.
"[Rick] Warren is "more reflective of the evangelical community than the Religious Right has ever been."
Brian Stiller - Tyndale University |
However, all the experts CC.com spoke to said there is no direct political connection. "These countries run separately on social and moral issues," said Stackhouse. Manning noted that Canadians elected a conservative government about the same time as Americans elected a liberal one.
Evangelicals in Canada don't have the same critical mass in Canada, said Stiller. There are three million evangelicals in Canada, compared to 90 million in the US, and Canadian evangelicals have therefore been less tempted to seek political power. Canadian televangelists David Mainse of 100 Huntley Street and Willard Thiessen of It's a New Day have deliberately chosen not to be politically partisan, he noted.
Manning said the same thing about Stiller's earlier leadership of the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada. The approach taken by Canadian evangelicals is "fundamentally different" from that taken by many American evangelicals, he said, "and beneficially so."
Stiller added that Canadians, including Canadian evangelicals, have a cultural bent toward fairness that recoils at the kinds of extremes sometimes evident in the US.
The weakening of the connection between American evangelicals and the Republican Party is "a healthy development," said Manning. "It is dangerous for faith communities to get identified exclusively with one party . . . A faith perspective should transcend party politics." He added that there should be Christian people on both sides subjecting policy to scrutiny.
Stiller agreed. "The lesson for us is that it is a huge mistake when politicians or voters get trapped into believing that faith and a party are, by nature of their doctrine, in lock step," he said. "For me, it is a good sign that the partisan evangelical connection no longer seems to rule (in the US). When faith becomes captured by an ideological and partisan focus, it sells its inheritance for a mess of political potage."
Related stories:
Some evangelicals prefer Barack Obama to Sarah Palin
A good proportion of US evangelicals, believe it or not, have a soft spot for Democrat presidential candidate Barack Obama. They're the evangelicals who are not impressed by John McCain's out-of-the-blue choice of Republican vice-presidential candidate Sarah Palin, a Pentecostal. They're also the evangelicals who don't think homosexuality and abortion are the nation's top two issues.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, October 17
Catholics find a way to oppose abortion while supporting Obama
Bishop Martino has been portrayed as extreme, an unfair accusation given that the right to life is a core position of Catholic teaching, not just one position among many. However, other Catholics have managed to view the abortion issue, in the light of national politics, in a different way -- reflecting a different American Catholic reality.
Charles Lewis, Full Comment, National Post, October 22
Pollsters: Conservatives' attack ads hurt voter turnout and democracy
The attack ads the Conservative Party of Canada launched during this fall's election campaign not only convinced some declared Liberals not to vote for their party, even more Canadians turned off entirely from voting.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, October 23
Sarah Palin losing her sway over Christian voters
The Sarah Palin effect, which brought evangelicals and other Christians rushing on to the Republican wagon when her nomination was announced, is now fading. In some cases fast.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, October 25
Messianic pretensions
Deeper than this: Obama has presented himself from the start as a messianic, "transformational" leader -- and thus played deceitfully with ideas that belong to religion and not politics. That he has done this so successfully is a mark of the degree to which the U.S. itself, like the rest of the western world, has lost its purchase on the Christian religion. Powerful religious impulses have been spilt, secularized. In this climate, people tend to be maniacally opposed to the sin to which they are not tempted: to giving Christ control over the things that are Caesar's. But they are blind to the sin to which they are hugely tempted: giving Caesar control over the things that are Christ's.
David Warren, Ottawa Citizen, October 25
Surprise? Three out of four US Jews now opting for Obama
If you weren't paying close attention, you would be led to believe by many in the media that most American Jews support the Republicans because George W. Bush, John McCain and Sarah Palin (all Christians) are staunch supporters of Israel's military conflicts with its mostly-Muslim neighbours. But a Gallup poll released on Thursday shows that most U.S. Jews are not polarized around Israel in the way pundits like to suggest.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, October 26
Routes to the ruling class
History will be made. Barack Obama will be the first black president, the first senator elected president since JFK in 1960 and the first president to have Illinois as a political base since Abraham Lincoln and Ulysses S. Grant, the twin victors of the Civil War. But it will also be business as usual. He will succeed President George W. Bush, educated at Yale and Harvard. Senator Obama was educated at Columbia and Harvard. That's change you can believe in.
Father Raymond J.De Souza, National Post, October 30
Republican's "Godless" attack ad make Canadian Conservative ads look tame
If you thought the Conservative Party of Canada's attack ads on Stephane Dion were bad, you ain't seen nothing yet. A prominent U.S. Republican senator has come out with what must be the most outrageous religion-based attack ad ever concocted.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, October 31
How eloquence shrank to election buzzwords
As the bestselling New York writer Sarah Vowell notes in her new book The Wordy Shipmates, there is a lot of carry-over rhetoric from the earliest English-American settlers to the present day. The original sermons uttered by Puritans washing ashore in the New World not only defined what was to become the American belief of a chosen land for a chosen people, their words still echo in today's stump speeches. But oh, how those original words have been maligned, says Vowell.
Globe and Mail, November 1
Top evangelical scholar: Many evangelicals appalled McCain chose Palin
I recently asked John Stackhouse, an influential scholar on faith and politics at evangelical Regent College in Vancouver, what evangelicals are thinking about Sarah Palin.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, November 4
A contested evangelical vote could give Obama the White House
This is going to be the election when white evangelical Christians, who make up 26 per cent of the U.S. electorate, actually may not decide the final vote in favour of the Republicans.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, November 4
Unlike in Canada, voting fraud widespread in U.S. states
My talented colleague Chad Skelton, who sits next to me in The Sun newsroom, has suggested several times in stories and on our online election tracker this evening that it is only exit polls that have been wrong in the past two U.S. elections. That's why he says they have often predicted strong Democrat showings that never materialized. But Skelton may be underestimating the major problems, and possible fraud, involved in recent years in voting in many American states and counties.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, November 4
Barack Obama may be winning over Catholics
The Catholic vote often flips between Democrats and Republicans in the U.S. It's not like the white evangelical vote, which is overwhelmingly Republican. But this election it looks as if Barack Obama is gathering together the swing Catholic vote in the U.S., which he needs to if he's going to emerge victorious. The large Catholic vote went to George W. Bush in the 2004 vote.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, November 4
Sarah Palin hurt the McCain campaign
As a long-term Pentecostal, Palin did the job of securing the white evangelical vote, which had been wavering for John McCain. Exit polls suggest the Republicans again won three out of four evangelical votes. That's worth about 40 million votes, if my math is correct. But the National Election exit poll showed Palin alienated most other voters.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, November 4
Remorseless Senator Liddy Dole receives just desserts for "Godless" ad
North Carolina, which went for Bush by a 12-point margin in 2004, appears to have decided that Dole's Christian hate-mongering should be a thing of the past.
Douglas Todd, The Search, Vancouver Sun, November 5
Keep it in perspective
Americans are very proud of themselves -- and why not? A black man in the Oval Office is a very big thing. Americans have discovered a star and made him president, as they have done so often -- Teddy Roosevelt, FDR, JFK, Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton. Some stars are flashy but little more -- JFK, Clinton. Others are truly transformational -- FDR, Reagan. What President Obama will be remains to be seen, but he will excel in the public theatre of the presidency, which is both welcome and important.
Father Raymond J. De Souza, National Post, November 6
November 6/2008
|
